Most organizations still treat their website like a digital brochure: a place to park information, list services, and paste in a mission statement. That’s a missed opportunity.
Your website is not a static document; it’s an ongoing conversation with real people who are curious, cautious, distracted, or ready to take action. When you see it that way, the question changes from “What do we want to say?” to “What does our visitor need to hear next?”
In this article, we’ll walk through seven key pages and show you the specific next action to feature on each—so you can turn visitors into participants, starting today.
1. Home: Start with “You,” Not “Us”
A brochure homepage says: “Welcome to [Organization]. We’ve been around since 1998. Here are all our services.”
A conversational homepage says, in effect: “You’re here because you’re trying to [solve a problem, achieve a goal, support a cause]. Here’s how we can help.”
Think about three things:
- Who is most likely landing here?
- What’s the problem your services can resolve?
- Is the next step presented to a site visitor in a clear, straightforward way to continue learning or connect with you?
Build a strong conversational homepage that includes:
- Create a clear, visitor‑focused headline that names their problem or desire for services (“Helping local nonprofits turn complex missions into clear stories.”).
- Include a short subheading that explains what you do, clearly and concisely.
- Consider one primary call to action (CTA) to drive the conversation forward. For example, lean into action steps: “Schedule a call,” “See how we help.”
- Be sure to include supporting sections that address early questions upon arrival, such as “What do you do?” “Who do you work with?” “Can I trust you?”
Consider: Does your homepage meet your visitor in a way that says, “I understand why you’re here,” then you’re right on track.
2. About: Make It About Them, Not You (You are the Guide)
The “About” page is where brochure thinking really shows up on many websites. This can sometimes include long timelines, internal jargon, and photos that are meaningful to the team but not vital to the visitor.
A conversational About page should answer: “Why should I trust you to help me?” and “Do you get my world?”
Try structuring your about page like this:
- Start with your visitor’s worldview.
Describe the challenges they face in their language that resonate. This shows empathy before credentials, leading to a connection point. - Introduce your role as a guide.
Talk about why you do this work, your values, and what you believe about how change happens. - Share proof, not a biography dump.
Highlight a few key milestones, types of clients, and impact—lean into what supports the story of why you’re a good fit for them. - Close with an invitation.
Encourage the next step. For example, that could be a link to read a case study, book a call, or download a helpful resource.
You still get to be human and tell your story, but every section should earn its place by answering, “How does this build trust for the person reading?”
3. Services/Programs: Speak in Outcomes, Not Menu Items
A brochure services page is a long list of offerings, often organized by internal departments or “what we do” categories.
A conversational services (or programs) page helps visitors see themselves in your work and understand what will change if they engage with you.
What to look out for:
- Prioritize “outcomes” over “activities”
If you’re a homeless outreach organization, for example, if you’re listing programs like “Drop-in Center, Case Management, Outreach,” try using language that connects to outcomes or solution-driven support: “Stabilize tonight with safe shelter,” “Create a pathway from the street to permanent housing,” “Remove barriers so families can rebuild their lives.” - Grouping by the visitor’s needs
Organize sections around the problems they bring to you (“Our website confuses more than it clarifies.”). Many nonprofits are talking to a variety of audiences—customers/clients, donors, and volunteers. You can organize and funnel these groups accordingly. - Maintain a simple and consistent structure per service offered
For every service or program that you offer, briefly outline and highlight: Who it’s for, what’s included, the value or result, and the typical path or timeline.
Keep in mind, your visitors are asking:
“Is this for someone like me?”
“What will this service or product actually do for us?”
“What will it be like to receive services from this [organization] or [business]?”
You have the opportunity to answer those questions clearly, leaving your visitor feeling confident in their choice.
4. Case Studies/Stories: Show, Don’t Just Say
Brochure‑style sites can tend to showcase “Portfolio” or “Success Stories” in a corner and focus mostly on surface‑level results.
Case studies are valuable assets. They walk the visitor through a story that aligns with their own lived experience. Here’s what a case study can look like:
- The situation: Where was this organization or client starting?
- The challenge: What isn’t working—confusing brand, messy website, scattered messages, low engagement?
- The approach: How did you collaborate, what decisions did you make together, what constraints did you work within?
- The outcome: What changed—clarity, confidence, donations, leads, participation?
- The takeaway: A short reflection that ties back to your values and approach.
Case studies don’t have to be long; they need to be specific. The goal is for a visitor to think and feel, “That sounds like us. If they could help [them], maybe they can help us too.”
5. Blog or Resources: Answer Frequently Asked Questions
A brochure treats the blog as a news bulletin board where you’re posting occasional announcements, internal celebrations, or sporadic posts with no thread. This is good content, but it often misses some great educational opportunities.
A conversational resource section is generous and strategic. It anticipates questions your audience is already asking themselves:
- “How do we know if we’re ready for a rebrand?”
- “What should we have prepared before hiring a designer or agency?”
- “How do we explain our work simply enough for a homepage?”
- “What should a small nonprofit website absolutely include?”
Use your blog to:
- Educate them on the process of working with you.
- Help the visitor make better decisions—even if they don’t choose to work with you right out the gate.
- Share your point of view and values in a way that feels useful, not preachy.
Every article is a conversation you’ve most likely already had 10 times with different clients. We all know this happens. Take the opportunity to put it in writing, in your voice, and assure and meet future visitors where they are.
6. Contact: Reduce Friction and Signal What Happens Next
A brochure contact page says, “Here’s a form. Good luck.” Sometimes forms fail to explain what will happen after submission, leaving your potential customer feeling “in the dark” or unsure if it even landed.
A conversational contact page should feel like the next step in a relationship that has already clicked and reassure the visitor that they are in good hands.
Review that your contact page is checking off the following:
- Sets expectations
Let your visitor know what will happen after they fill out your form. For example, an auto-reply that states: “We’ll respond within two business days,” “We’ll schedule a 20‑minute introductory call,” or “We’ll review your details and connect for next steps.” - Asks only for what you truly need
The more fields, the more friction it can create. Ask for just enough to get what you need to respond thoughtfully. This should include their name, email address, organization, and a brief description of their needs. - Makes them feel welcomed, not judged
Use friendly, plain language. If you work with a specific type of client, say that clearly but kindly, so people can self‑select without feeling isolated, judged, or shut out.
This is also a good place to gently restate who you’re best suited to help, so it’s clear and respectful on both sides.
7. The “Action” Page: Donate, Book, Apply, or Join
Many organizations put enormous pressure on their “big ask” page—Donate, Book Now, Apply, Join—while giving visitors very little conversational context for the decision.
A brochure mindset says: “You’ve arrived at the form. Fill it out.”
A conversational mindset says, “You’re considering doing something meaningful. This is what this action or next step means, why it matters, and how we’ll steward it.”
Strengthen your action page by identifying:
- Clarification on the “why” at the top of a form
Consider including the impact on forms. How does this donation, booking, or application step support the end-user’s needs or efforts? - Reduce friction in the decision-making process
For example, if you’re taking donations, offer a few suggested amounts or options, explain choices in plain language, and remove any unnecessary fields. - Answering last‑minute doubts or concerns
Address any security and privacy concerns, how funds are used, what happens next, and who to contact with questions.
Your action page acts as the moment in the conversation when someone says “yes” to what you’re offering. Your job is to ensure the user feels informed and confident in your support.
Bringing It All Together
When your website is built like a conversation instead of a brochure, every page has a job and serves a deeper purpose, creating a valuable resource. In summary, each page should embody the following:
- Home: “You’ve come to the right place.”
- About: “You can trust us to guide you.”
- Services (or Programs): “Here’s how we can help you.”
- Case Studies: “Here’s proof that our services (or products) work for people like you.”
- Resources: “Here’s what you’re wondering, answered honestly.”
- Contact: “Here’s how to take the next step, without friction.”
- Action Page: “Here’s what your yes means, and what happens next.”
If your current site feels more like a brochure, there’s good news! You don’t have to rebuild everything tomorrow. Start with one page, choose a clear action you want your ideal visitor to take, and rewrite that page to guide them directly to it.
Your website isn’t just where information lives. It’s where relationships begin.
If you’re ready to rethink how your site greets visitors, guides them, and invites them to act, and you’re not entirely sure where to begin, let’s take a look together and identify the first few changes that will make the biggest difference. Book a call.
Pantone’s Color of the Year for 2025, 
